Oktawian Nawrot. Department for Logic, Methodology and Philosophy of Science , University of. Gdansk .. Ziembiński Z., Logika praktyczna¸ Warszawa Wprowadzenie do logiki dla prawnikow [StpieSporek Anna Nawrot Oktawian i deontycznych a takze logika erotetyczna Najnowsze wydanie uzupelnione. , p. , Oktawian Nawrot and Filip Przybylski-Lewandowski, Wnioskowania , Chaim Perelman, Logika prawnicza: Nowa retoryka.
|Published (Last):||27 January 2012|
|PDF File Size:||9.40 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||14.13 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Rivista internazionale di filosofia del diritto oktawia 1: Principles, Rules, Hints], 6th rev. However, this amendment is only indirectly grounded on an extensional criterion. Naturally, the preparatory activities of an interpreter do not necessarily take place prior to the activities belonging okawian the next phase of interpretation.
Therefore, the principles of clara non sunt interpretanda and interpretatio cessat in claris must be abandoned altogether. The standard subject of the understanding and of the operative interpretation of the law is the court. Clausdieter Schott In his earlier works, he mainly referred to the principle of interpretatio cessat in claris or to the doctrine of claritas lex clara and, but very rarely, to the rule in claris non fit interpretatio.
Pobierz PDF Oktawian Nawrot Logika
A manwho is not a mother, acting under influence of the labour and during it, in relation to the child, and who lgoika not a person, which in necessary defence is repelling any direct and illegal attack against any social good or any personal good, and who is not an authorised person executing a legally valid death penalty, and who is not a soldier acting against the enemy during the war hostilities not in a way inconsistent with the laws of war, is ordered thatin any circumstances from the 1 st of Januaryshe does not killand even does not attempt to kill neither under the influence of the strong emotion, nor on demand of the other man and under the influence of a compassion for her, a man.
A never-ending controversy in Polish legal theory? Consequently, legal language has to tolerate the existence of interpretive doubt, even concerning the question of whether a text must or must not be interpreted. In Polish juristic language, as in the German language, two terms exist that are used in the discourse of legal interpretation: Fifthly, according to the current view, the clarificative theory is related to the context of justification of interpretive decisions, whilst the derivational theory is surely logiak focussed on the context of discovery.
Clara non sunt interpretanda vs. omnia sunt interpretanda
It is worth adding that his analyses are also relevant to the purely phi In both cases, the conviction that the rule of law has been broken can easily arise on the side of the citizen.
The meaning of a norm a pattern of the ought behaviour sufficiently determined for deciding a given legal case.
Wydawnictwo Naukowe Uniwersytetu im. The omnia sunt interpretanda principle narwot the power of the judges by increasing the possibility of the application of various interpretive techniques especially extra-linguistic oneswhich the citizens simply do not know.
It is obvious that the pragmatic clarity of the law which takes place in the situation of isomorphy is not equivalent to the semantic univocity of legal norms. He points out that we can identify the doubts, which justify the thesis that lex non clara estonly if we engage in legal interpretation.
Law, Truth, and Reason. It is a pity, but I think that this dictum, mutatis mutandiscan be referred to the derivational theory of legal interpretation. Firstly, the discussed nawroy meta-principles are applied in the oktawiam majority of cases without being explicitly mentioned by the judges.
I suppose that at this point we do not have any controversy: However, in order to propose a solution to the controversy, it is indeed indispensable to anyone interested in finding such a solution. Neither as a starting point nor as an ending point of the understanding of a text is clarity an absolute given.
Maybe his aspiration is axiologically justifiable, yet I think that it is utopian. For instance, Clausdieter Schott maintains that the maxim interpretatio cessat in claris was invented by the lawyers of the Renaissance: This interpretation is thus a case-bound interpretation.
Argumenta non numeranda, sed ponderanda sunt! It is, obviously, the concept of isomorphy that fulfils this function: Polska kultura prawna a proces integracji europejskiej. T he result of interpretation. Lech Morawski Przepis prawny a norma prawna [Legal Provision and Legal Norm]. Interpretation and Legal Theory. The omnia sunt interpretanda principle and the derivational theory of interpretation in general has a normative character. Statute of 19 June ].
Polish Contributions to the Theory and Philosophy of Law. But the semantic univocity can probably be treated only as a regulative idea of juristic interpretive reasoning, mainly because of practical and epistemological reasons open texture, defeasibility, interpretive regressus ad infinitum. Avtorske pravice All rights reserved Vrh strani.